Pony Island Motel www.ponyislandmotel.com OnlineWebsite - www.ponyislandmotel.comSend an email - email@example.comAddress785 Irvin Garrish HighwayOcracoke, NC 27960Mailing Address - PO Box 309Ocracoke, NC 27960PhonePrimary - (252) 928-4411TripAdvisor Traveler RatingBased on 124 reviews Come relax near the beach with us. The restaurant is Ocracoke’s oldest eatery. We are open daily for breakfast from 7 am to 11 am and dinner from 5 to 9 pm. Big southern style breakfast and our famous Pony potatoes. Fresh seafood, steaks, pastas and daily specials and carryout. Beer and wine. Handicapped accessible. TripAdvisorTripAdvisor Traveler RatingBased on 124 reviewsSee all 124 reviews.Write a review.